History
The Mismeasure of Learning Disability: The Contentious Career of the “IQ‐Achievement” Discrepancy
ABSTRACT
The existence of a “severe discrepancy” between measured ability and achievement has been the dominant criterion for identifying learning disabilities (“LD”) in American education since its codification into federal law in 1977. In this article, I argue that the history of LD is best understood not through the emergence of a diagnostic label, but through the evolution of its methods of identification. By tracing the rise and decline of the IQ–achievement discrepancy model amid shifting legal, psychometric, and policy contexts, I aim to show how declining faith in IQ tests as measures of potential threatened the credibility of LD as a viable construct for identifyin and treating “unexpected” underachievement. Abandoning discrepancy and embracing more pragmatic approaches like response to intervention (RTI) reflected political compromises as much as discrepancy had represented decades before. But it also represented an effort by experts in the LD field to protect the scientific integrity of LD by more effectively targeting its most recognizable characteristic—the failure to learn in comparison to age-level peers. In the era of standards and accountability, this shift reflected the priorities of education reformers and the legislative impetus of No Child Left Behind. But it also represented a profound reorientation of the measurement of unexpected underachievement. By supplanting an increasingly discredited metric of intellectual potential (IQ), RTI and similar methods helped reinterpret LD as a specifically skills-based construct unrelated to perennially ambiguous notions of intelligence.
Journal Article Abstracts
-
Ethical framework for AI-augmented evaluator judgment: Navigating professional autonomy, accountability, and algorithmic authority in program evaluation
-
Decision-making factors in insanity defence assessment: A systematic review
-
Migration and Education Choices: How Low‐Skilled Migration Shapes the Educational Attainment of Mexican Youth
-
Decreased diffusivity along the perivascular spaces mediates REM sleep reduction and gray matter atrophy in the default mode network (DMN) among patients with insomnia
-
Psychoeducation for Youth at Clinical High‐Risk of Psychosis
-
Association of Pubertal Timing and Progression with Variation in the Dual Systems Imbalance Gap: The Moderating Role of Autism Spectrum Disorder
Open Access Journal Articles
-
Prevalence of emotional blunting and its association with childhood adverse experiences in depressive episodes
-
One Person, How Many Votes? Demographic Distortions in United States Elections
-
How do substance use behaviors change across housing hardship transitions? Asymmetric effects on smoking, binge drinking, and marijuana use in young adulthood
-
Clinician stakeholder priorities for improving the management of non-traumatic wrist disorders in the UK: a nominal group technique study
-
Underfunded and undervalued: community-based health promotion practitioners’ experiences of Western Australia’s prevention sector
Guidelines Plus
-
Updates to the Guidelines for the Use of Antiretroviral Agents in Adults and Adolescents With HIV
-
Principles for Good Governance
Meta-analyses - Systematic Reviews
-
The effectiveness of artificial intelligence in undergraduate health professions education: Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
-
Needs of Rural Caregivers of Patients With Cancer: A Scoping Review of Evidence From North America, Europe, and Australia
Monographs & Edited Collections
more Monographs & Edited CollectionsNews
Student Spotlight: Vina Cuevas

CSUDH student Vina Cuevas is a busy woman. She’s not only pursuing a master’s degree in social work, but is also working, doing an internship, assisting a professor with a research project, preparing to present at an international conference – and was also recently named a 2026–2027 Council on Social Work Education (CSWE) Minority Fellowship Program Fellow.
Grey Literature
-
What We Need to Measure to Understand Community College Outcomes
-
The state of health care and adult social care in England 2025/26
-
Care Inspectorate Wales’ Annual Report shows strong quality of care although sector pressures remain
-
General practice: health of the nation 2026: Recognising 10 years of insight into the state of Australian general practice
-
Is Every Metropolitan Area Actually Short on Housing?
Podcasts
more PodcastsCalls & Consultations
-
Fwd: Mental Wellbeing and Sustainable Care Workforce – Practices and European Perspectives
-
2nd Online Policy Lab – Mental Wellbeing and Sustainable Care Workforce – Practices and European Perspectives



