Differential reinforcement of alternative behavior (DRA), which often arranges extinction (EXT) for destructive behavior, is an effective treatment to reduce destructive behavior. However, the use of EXT has several limitations resulting in practitioners implementing DRA without EXT. During these treatments, practitioners often manipulate reinforcer dimensions to favor appropriate behavior. The pre-identification of reinforcer dimensions to which an individual’s behavior is sensitive may be important to inform efficacious DRA without EXT treatments. In Study 1, we extended developed a systematic methodology to assess individual sensitivity to reinforcer dimensions. In Study 2, we implemented two DRA without EXT procedures to assess if individuals allocated responding towards the response that produced baseline reinforcer parameters relative to the response that produced the parametrically changed reinforcer to which the individuals demonstrated sensitivity during Study 1. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved)