Brooding and Reflection Reconsidered: A Factor Analytic Examination of Rumination in Currently Depressed, Formerly Depressed, and Never Depressed Individuals

The tendency to engage in depressive rumination is typically measured with the Ruminative Response Styles (RRS) scale. Treynor
et al. (2003) reported that this scale is composed of two 5-item factors, reflection and brooding, and that the brooding but not the reflection
factor is associated with more severe depression over time. These two factors were derived using data from a randomly selected
community sample, and it is not clear if these factors would be obtained in samples of currently depressed, formerly depressed,
and never depressed individuals. We conducted factor analyses on scores on the RRS scale from three such samples. We found
support for the distinction between reflection and brooding in never depressed and formerly depressed individuals; we did
not obtain this distinct factor structure in the currently depressed sample. We did, however, find evidence of a second factor
in the depressed sample that we labeled ‘intentional rumination.’ The results of this study also suggested that an item from
the reflection factor should be replaced with another item from the RRS scale. These findings indicate that the distinction
between brooding and reflection is blurred in currently depressed individuals.