Noncustodial fatherhood, referring to fathering from a separate household, is a widespread and complex phenomenon. However, the experiences of noncustodial fathers in disadvantaged neighborhoods have received limited scholarly attention. This qualitative study employs an ecological model of father involvement to examine how the physical, social, and cultural characteristics of a disadvantaged neighborhood shape paternal engagement. Drawing on in-depth interviews with twenty noncustodial fathers residing in a disadvantaged urban neighborhood in Israel, the analysis identifies three central themes: (1) experiences of physical neglect and spatial exclusion, (2) experiences of belonging and recognition within the community, and (3) the dual role of neighborhood culture in facilitating connections and imposing restrictions. The findings indicate that deteriorating neighborhood conditions hinder fathers’ ability to maintain meaningful relationships with their children, while strong community ties and cultural recognition reinforce paternal identity and resilience. Yet neighborhood norms centered on survival and limited aspirations may perpetuate intergenerational disadvantage. This study extends Cabrera’s model by elucidating how local contexts influence both the opportunities and limitations of father involvement. It emphasizes addressing structural inequalities and utilizing community assets to foster meaningful fatherhood in disadvantaged settings, especially where fathers occupy peripheral roles within family life.